Sleep Related

Casper vs Tuft and Needle vs Leesa: 7 Questions To Help You Decide

casper vs tuft and needle vs leesaMost of the time when people ask me for a mattress comparison it’s only between 2 different mattresses. But sometimes it happens that I get asked to do a comparison between 3 mattresses. You may have heard about them: they’re all getting good reviews on all the major mattress sites. And that’s why today we’re going to discuss the Casper vs Tuft and Needle vs Leesa mattress. So if you’re in doubt which one of these will be the perfect one for you – please continue reading.

Note: every person is different so your needs will be different from mine and form the next person reading this. That’s why there’s no definitive answer to which mattress is the *best*. What there is, however, is a mattress which is the *best for you*. So I highly recommend you ask yourself beforehand what you value in a mattress – maybe even talk with your spouse about it. That way you’ll have a better image of what type of mattress you want. And the choice will become a lot easier.

In this article we’ll first discuss what makes the 3 mattresses similar. After that we’ll take each mattress and examine it. I’ll also tell you what I found the most interesting about each mattress. After that we’ll have a list of questions that will help you make your decision which mattress is best for you.

Casper vs Tuft and Needle vs Leesa

Now, all 3 mattresses have quite a bit in common. For example, they’re all foam mattresses. And they’re all pretty new on the mattress scene. Here’s an overview of everything that these 3 mattresses have in common:

  • Memory foam mattresses
  • Can be bought online (and shipped to your door)
  • Are 10 inches thick
  • Offer a 100-night sleeping trial (risk-free purchase)
  • Have a 10-year warranty

So, the main things I want to draw attention to here is the mattresses are medium thickness and that they are memory foam mattresses that are medium firm. So in terms as far as mattresses go – they are all good for the majority of people. So you should be fine with each choice. However, each mattress has its own things and details that may make it a better (or worse) fit for you.

We’ll discuss that in the following paragraphs.

What I like about the Casper mattress: incredible service

One of the first things that you’ll notice is that the Casper mattress is a very comfortable mattress. It’s made from premium latex foam and it really seems to hit that sweet sport of not too firm – but also not too soft. So it’s a good mattress if you like mattresses that have their firmness in the middle.

Another thing that Casper really seems to do well is their customer service. For instance, if you still have an old mattress that you have no place to put it – the guys that will bring your mattress can also take it away. And if you have a problem, you can always count on them to help top you.

One negative ting though is that some people find that the mattress keeps its chemical smell for quite a long time. So if you’re unable to open the window in the first couple of weeks while sleeping, that might be a reason not to get the Casper mattress.

What I like about the Tuft & Needle mattress: premium mattress – but a price class lower

The Tuft and Needle is a great mattress in itself. The main thing that you’ll notice with this mattress is its simplicity. And that’s not only in its appearance. It only has 2 layers of foam – instead of the 3 or more of most other mattresses.

That is because when designing the mattress, the company made sure to focus only on the things that matter most for sleeping: comfort and support. This is in order to make a great mattress that is also affordable for the majority of people.

This has paid off, since the mattress has a much lower price tag than the other 2 mattresses in this comparison. So if you’re on a budget – the Tuft & Needle might be the perfect mattress for you.

One drawback, however, is that it might be too simple for some people. Some things such as edge support didn’t make the cut for the mattress. Some people might need it, but most don’t, so the company decided not to include this.

What I like about the Leesa mattress: comfort + charity

One of the first things you might come to know about the Leesa mattress is that they have a giving pledge. What this means is that for every 10 mattresses that they sell – they give 1 mattress to a homeless shelter. I’m always happy to see if a company decides to take their profits and do something more to better the world instead of just selling a good product and hording all the profits. So if you’re anything like me, this will resonate with you as well.

But of course it’s also important how the mattress sleeps. The Leesa mattress is a very comfortable mattress. Here’s how it’s built:

  • 2-inch top layer that keeps you cool and conforms to your body
  • 2-inch memory foam layers that relieves pressure on painful parts of your body (such as hips of lower back)
  • 6-inch base layer for support and stability

So, just like the other 2 mattresses, it’s a 10-inch mattress. The Leesa mattress is most suited for you if you value comfort – and don’t have to worry too much about your budget. Oh, of course the giving pledge may also convince you to choose Leesa.

Here’s what to base your decision on (Casper vs Tuft and Needle vs Leesa)

A lot of information about these 3 mattresses, so you might not be completely sure which one to pick. I’ve dropped some hints in the previous paragraphs, but let’s make it a bit more clear:

  • Do you want a premium mattress for an affordable price? Pick Tuft & Needle
  • Do you want very good customer service? Casper mattress
  • Is comfort the thing you desire most? Leesa will have you covered
  • Do you sleep very hot? Leesa or Casper will be a great choice
  • Do you want to keep the mattress for 10+ years? Leesa or Casper mattress
  • Do you need edge support? Leesa or Casper
  • Do you care about charity? Leesa mattress

Final verdict Casper vs Tuft and needle vs Leesa

So there you have it. In general I’d say that if you’re on a budget, pick Tuft & Needle. And if you don’t then it will be a choice between Casper and Leesa. Leesa wins on comfort but the Casper mattress also has a lot of good things going for it.

I recommend you check out the links below for more information about each mattress. You’ll also have the option to buy directly, so you won’t have to go looking for any other place.

I hope this article has made it more clear to you which mattress is the better choice for you. And if you have any questions (after checking the links below), you can always leave a comment. I’d be happy to help you out.


Click here for more information about the Tuft & Needle mattress!


Or here to check out the Casper mattress!


And everything you need to know about the Leesa mattress can be found here!



P.S. enjoyed this Casper vs Tuft and Needle vs Leesa comparison? Than support the site by buying through one of the links above! Your help is very appreciated in keeping the site up and running.

By Adrianus

Since childhood I've tried hundreds of little experiments to feel better, learn faster and perform higher (e.g. supplements, sports, psychological tricks, sleep and wacky diets).
After I graduated university in 2016, I basically found that sleep was the #1 factor to improve every aspect of life.
Bad sleep = bad life. I started SleepInvestor in 2017 to share my experiments and thoughts about sleep.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *