Simmons Beautyrest vs Stearns & Foster
Simmons Beautyrest
Silver BRS900 model
Stearns & Foster
Estate Oak Terrace model
Simmons Beautyrest
What do I like?
Good durability, sleeps cool and overall good choice.
Any negatives?
Customer support better at Stearns & Foster
Price
Summary
Lower entry price point – which makes it a good choice if you’re not ready to spend $1000+ on a mattress.
Stearns & Foster
What do I like?
Targeted foams for extra layers of comfort
Any negatives?
Durability may not be as good (compared to Simmons Beautyrest)
Price?
Summary
High quality mattress that comes with the price you expect for quality.
2 of the oldest U.S. mattress companies are Stearns & Foster and Simmons. They both make high quality mattresses aimed at the higher end of the market. But how do they add up? Find out everything you need to know about the comparison between Stearns and Foster vs Beautyrest:
Stearns and Foster vs Beautyrest
Stearns & Foster is a mattress company that has been producing mattresses since the mid 1800s. Sealy (from Tempurpedic) acquired the company on 2012 and they have improved the customer experience since. The original Stearns & Foster mattresses, however, stayed the same.
Simmons Beautyrest also goes back to the 1800s (a bit later then Stearns & Foster). So both companies have been around for a long time – and if you value companies that contribute to the U.S. economy – you can go with both companies.
Here’s an overview of the similarities between both mattresses:
- Each company offers different mattresses based on budget, normal and premium.
- Mattresses are made with traditional coils for support
- And comfort material (foam) on top
- Both mattresses can be bought in regular retail stores
- But are also available online.
- Both mattress companies offer good edge support
- And motion transfer is also very good.
So as you can see for both mattress companies you’ve got a wide variety of choice. Both work by having coils (or micro pocketed coils) in the lower support layer. This ensure that your spine is correctly aligned.
The problem however with only coils, is that it can cause a lot of problems sleeping. Your body has to adapt to the bed – and the other way around is more comfortable. Luckily, the foam on top solves this problem by adapting to your body.
Here’s why you’d go for Stearns & Foster:
Stearns and Foster offers 3 different collections:
Stearns & Foster Estate collection is the budget line. They use 2 types of foam (dapative foam and PrimaSense gel) to contour the body. The top Prima cool performance fabric on the outside ensure that you sleep cool.The coils are individually wrapped and provide the support for the mattress.The edges are reinforced to give more edhe support.
The Stearns & Foster Lux Estate collection has everything that the Estate has. But the mattress is tufted by hand for better durability. The mattress upper layer is a pillow support layer, which hugs your body more and is slightly more comfortable.
The Stearns & Foster Lux Estate Hybrid is like the regular Lux, but uses more foam and less spring (50/50). The bed responds more to your movements and also the edge support is improved.
Stearns and Foster mattresses are great. The best purchase I have ever made. After I figured out what type of sleeper I was, I spent a year researching and testing different beds and pillows. Its been 6 years now and I still love it.
— Jen (@Mitchejmsays) 31 augustus 2019
[tcb-script async=”” src=”https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js” charset=”utf-8″][/tcb-script]
Stearns & Foster Reserve is the premium mattress. It has the best of all the above mattresses, but adds different targeted foams for extra support and durability. The gel foam ensures that heat can easily escape from the mattress. And the hybrid pillowtop technology increases the comfort of the upper layers.
As far as price and warranty go, the thing with Stearns & Foster is that you’re dealing with your own mattress retailer. And they create the terms for the warranty. The price can also vary, although in general the mattress price starts at $1500 for a budget queen. But this can go up in the $3000 for the luxury mattresses. So if you’re going for the Stearns & Foster mattress – be sure to shop around a bit. (or go online, that way you’ll skip a lot of the retailer fees).
Stearns & Foster
Sleep
Stearns & Foster offer a high quality mattress that helps many people sleep better. Especially if you prefer comfort and support.
Longevity
The mattress have a high longevity, although people suggest that it could be longer for the price.
Cost
The mattress can be quite pricey. If you’re serious about improving your sleep, this can be completely worth it though.
Overall rating : 4.5 / 5
This is why you’d pick Beautyrest:
Beautyrest also has 4 different model mattresses:
Beautyrest Silver is the budget mattress. It uses memory foam on top for comfort and cooling, and micro coils for support. You can choose between different options (such as an innerspring model or hybrid).
The Beautyrest Platinum is the regular option. This one is a better choice if you’re having back problems. The mattresses are more supportive around your spine to offer full alignment there. You can also choose between different firmness options here.
The Beautyrest Black is the luxury option. Here the main difference is that there’s more cooling (so if you sleep hot, this is a good option). The coils are micro pocketed, which allow for more air flow. In general the Black is a great option if you value comfort – but also want optimal support for your spine.
Beautyrest black ice. That’s what I got because I have lots of back issues and hip issues. And this mattress is life changing
— katiekitten (@katiekitten240) 4 september 2019
[tcb-script async=”” src=”https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js” charset=”utf-8″][/tcb-script]
The Beautyrest Bed in a Box is for when you want a good mattress, but don’t want to deal with all the support and customer service. It’s a good memory foam mattress (with coils is tough to deliver in a box). It also includes a sleep tracker – so you can check on your smartphone how well you’re sleeping.
The Beautyrest mattress start from $700 for the budget queen, and their warranty can be found n the company site. So here the Beautyrest wins.
The durability of Beautyrest is also considered to be better than the mattresses from Stearns & Foster – so if you’re thinking of making an investment for the long-term (which these mattresses are), you’re better choosing Beautyrest.
Simmons Beautyrest
Sleep
Simmons Beautyrest mattresses are optimized for alignment around your spine and comfort.
Longevity
The mattresses will stay well for a long period of time and they’ll experience minimal sagging.
Cost
Entry prices are much lower than for the Stearns & Foster mattresses. Especially for the silver models.
Overall rating : 4.0 / 5
Stearns and Foster vs Beautyrest guidelines:
Maybe you’ve already decided between Stearns and Foster vs Beautyrest. If not, here are some guidelines to help you decide:
- if price matters to you, then Beautyrest has more options available for you.
- If you want a good customer support, pick Stearns & Foster.
- With durability, the Beautyrest also wins, since it costs less and has slightly better durability.
- All the other things are very equal. The quality, and different choices in mattress options and types are good at both companies.
Stearns & Foster vs Beautyrest conclusion
We recommend you get the Beautyrest. Since both mattress companies are very similar, it’s difficult to go wrong with any. But the Beautyrest offers more options for a better price. Unless you specifically want one of the Stearns & Foster mattress lines, then it’s better to pick Beautyrest.
Simmons Beautyrest vs Stearns & Foster
Simmons Beautyrest
Silver BRS900 model
Stearns & Foster
Estate Oak Terrace model
Simmons Beautyrest
What do I like?
Good durability, sleeps cool and overall good choice.
Any negatives?
Customer support better at Stearns & Foster
Price
Summary
Lower entry price point – which makes it a good choice if you’re not ready to spend $1000+ on a mattress.
Stearns & Foster
What do I like?
Targeted foams for extra layers of comfort
Any negatives?
Durability may not be as good (compared to Simmons Beautyrest)
Price?
Summary
High quality mattress that comes with the price you expect for quality.
P.S. enjoyed reading this Stearns and Foster vs Beautyrest comparison? Then we recommend you order your Beautyrest mattress online. This way you’ll skip a large part of the fees associated to regular retailers. Get your Beautyrest mattress online now!
