Chances are you’re contemplating between the Loom and Leaf vs Tuft and Needle mattress. Both mattresses receive many good customer reviews (both online and offline), so it’s not a matter of black and white. That’s why in this comparison I want to shed a light on the critical differences that the mattresses have. Because it is those differences that make each mattress more attractive to specific types of sleepers. So in essence we’re going to discuss what type of sleeper you are – and then couple that with the mattresses so you’ll know which one will suit your better.
Note: because both mattresses suit to different people, it’s important that you ask yourself what is important to you: do you need a firm mattress for ample back support? Or are you looking for a mattress that just does the job and you can get for a cheaper price (maybe you’re not planning on sleeping on it for the next 10+ years). So ask yourself – or have a little chat with your partner – what is important for you in a mattress. It’ll save you a ton of decision stress later on.
Loom and Leaf vs Tuft and Needle
Before we discuss the differences, I first want to give you a little overview of the similarities of both. That way you’ll get a better feeling for what you can expect – regardless of your choice. It’ll help you realize whether either mattress is good enough for – and the differences between them will help make that final decision a lot easier for you.
- Are foam mattresses (T&N is polyfoam – L&L is all memory foam)
- Are only available online
- Receive good customer reviews
- Can be delivered at home
- Offer a warranty of 10 years or more
- Have a low-risk testing policy (you have 100 nights for T&N – 120 for L&L – to test the mattress in the comfort of your own home)
I’m very happy to see a test trial for both mattresses. Knowing you can test-sleep the mattress for at least 3 months always takes away a lot of the pre-purchase headache. I’m surprised not every mattress is doing this nowadays, but Loom & Leaf and Tuft & Needle do – so that’s always a reassuring sign.
Now, on to the differences between each mattress – and what surprised me the most about each.
What I like about the Loom and Leaf mattress: luxury memory foam (slow sinking)
The first thing you’ll notice is that the Loom and Leaf mattress is a pretty thick mattress. With its 12.93 inches it’s sure on the thicker side. SO if you like that, then Loom and Leaf is a perfect choice Here’s how the mattress is built up:
- 2-inch PCF Polyfoam
- 5-inch PCF Polyfoam
- 5-inch PCF Gel Memory Foam
- 2-inch PCF Memory Foam
- 5/8-inch Foam Quilted with Organic Cotton
What this means in more concrete ‘how does it sleep’ terms is that the mattress is a 5.5 on the firmness scale of 1-10. It’s a traditional memory foam mattress, so what you’ll notice when you lie on it that it does a very good job at comfort. You’ll slowly start sinking into it. And that makes the mattress very comfortable. You can see that they pulled out all the stops to make sure that you really have a luxury feeling on it.
There is a downside however, and that is that it does come with a higher price tag. But if you’re not restricted by a tight budget – I’d say to give Loom and Leaf a try.
What I like about the Tuft and Needle mattress: premium mattress for an affordable price
Now, I’m not going to say that the Tuft & Needle mattress really sleeps worse on a comparable basis. But you should know that the mattress simply doesn’t have that *luxury* thing that Loom and Leaf has. However, it is a very comfortable mattress for the price.
It’s around 10 inches thick. Here’s an overview of all the layers:
- 7-inch PCF Polyfoam
- 3-inch PCF Polyfoam
So as you see it’s a lot simpler than the Loom and Leaf mattress. It’s around a 6.5 firmness on a scale of 1-10 (so a bit more firm than Loom and Leaf). And the great thing about this is that you get a mattress without any extra frills. And that is something that you see in the price. The Tuft & Needle company does a very good job in transparency. So if you’re curious you can exactly find out how the price of the mattress is built up.
So, the Tuft & Needle mattress was made to offer your 2 things: comfort and support. Which is, in my opinion what around 75% of people need. If you’ve got a comfortable mattress that offers ample support for your back and posture – what else do you need?
So if you’re on a budget – or prefer more simple mattresses – then you can almost not go wrong with the Tuft & Needle mattress.
What should you base your decision on
I already dropped some hints throughout this Loom and Leaf vs Tuft and Needle comparison. But to make it even easier I’ve compiled a short a question list you can ask yourself to become more clear which mattress is right for you:
- Do you want a premium mattress for an affordable price? Tuft & Needle has got you covered
- Or do you want a real luxury feeling and price isn’t an issue? Pick the Loom and Leaf mattress
- Do you prefer the soft sinking of real memory foam? Loom and Leaf has exactly that
- Or do you want a firmer mattress with all-polyfoam? In that case choose Tuft and Needle.
Oh, one thing I forgot to mention in the previous paragraphs. I have no personal experience with this, but many reviews online say that the Loom and leaf mattress does a phenomenal job for keeping motion transfer down. What this means is that if you sometimes wake up from the movements of your partner on the other side of the bed – your mattress scores poor for motion transfer.
So if that’s something that keeps you awake at night, the Loom & leaf mattress can help you.
Final verdict Loom and Leaf vs Tuft and Needle
We’ve reached the end of this comparison. So here a quick recap of the Loom and Leaf vs Tuft and Needle mattresses. Both mattresses are perfectly fine in terms of quality and sleeping experience. However, the Loom and Leaf does have a more luxury feel to it. So if you’re all for that and you have the budget – it’s an easy choice.
However, if you are on a budget, then I recommend picking the Tuft & Needle mattress. The price difference is significant. And maybe in a couple of years you will be earning more, so that you can then buy a more luxury mattress.
Anyway, I hope that you’ve become more clear on what mattress suits you. Now, the next thing for you to do is check out the product page for the mattress you chose. You’ll find a ton of extra useful information there and also some helpful customer reviews.
P.S. Did this Loom and Leaf vs Tuft and Needle comparison help you out? You can check out the mattress you chose through the above link – and if you’re sure (don’t forget the 100-night sleeping trial), you can order the mattress directly.