Sleep Related

Zinus vs Tuft and Needle Mattress: 4 Guidelines to Help You Decide

zinus vs tuft and needle mattressSleep is incredibly important. Most people need around 8 hours of good sleep every night in order to get the most out of their lives. That’s why it is a good idea to make sure that the mattress you’re sleeping on is of high quality. But what if you don’t have thousands of dollars to spend on a good mattress? Then you’re forced to look at other variants. And it probably won’t surprise you that there are many mattresses available for an affordable price. That’s why today we’ll discuss Zinus vs Tuft and Needle mattress. Both mattresses are in the low-medium price range (as far as memory foam mattresses go). And it’s a question I often receive here on the blog.

zinus vs tuft needle mattress

Note: every person is different so it’s difficult to give a one-size-fits-all advice. What I can do however, is give you a good overview of each mattress + the different types of people who are more likely to enjoy one specific mattress vs another.

First, we’ll discuss the similarities between the 2 mattresses (so you get a good image), then I’ll show you the things I like most about each mattress (the differences). Finally I’ve made a list of questions you can ask yourself to find out which mattress suits you better.

So, let’s get started with this Zinus vs Tuft and Needle comparison!

Zinus vs Tuft and Needle

Both mattresses are similar in a couple of ways. To start, they’re both memory foam mattresses. So you’ll sleep well on them (click here for more information what a memory foam mattress exactly is).

As for thickness, the Zinus mattress is 12 inches thick, and the Tuft & Needle mattress 10 – so there’s not a big difference here. Also, the firmness of both mattresses is medium – so that’s the perfect mean for people who don’t want to sleep on too soft mattresses, but also want to feel like they’re sleeping on the floor.

Another thing you’ll get with each mattress is a 100-night sleeping trial. What that means is that after you order the mattress, you’ll have a little over 3 months to find out how you like sleeping on the mattress. This is a great thing, since it’ll allow you to delay the final decision until after you know how well the mattress sleeps. And in case you’re not satisfied – you can simply return the mattress for a refund.

Both mattresses also offer a 10-year guarantee – so if you happen to find some production fault in the coming years, you’ll be covered for that.

Now, onto the differences!

What I like about the Zinus mattress: comfortable high mattress with minimal *bounce*

zinus vs tuft and needle mattress

First thing you’ll notice after the Zinus mattress has expanded (takes around 24-48 hours) is that it’s a higher mattress. With 12 inches it will show off above your box spring or bed. So if you like mattresses on the higher side that’s a good thing here. Some people say the mattress is a bit on the firmer side compared to what they are saying on the product page of Zinus. However, that goes away in some time and the mattress become s a bit more soft – so on the medium side. This + its thickness makes it perfect for people who are on the heavier side though.

Another thing I like is that the mattress has minimal bounce. So if your partner is moving a lot at night and you wake up because of that – the Zinus mattress can help you get better sleep.

Now, the mattress also claims to have green tea extract inside. I’m a little unsure what that means, but at least it doesn’t smell like green tea! So it’s an interesting, but in the end quite useless extra. Maybe if you have some more to say about that, please leave it in the comments.

zinus green tea

Also, the Zinus mattress is the more affordable mattress in this Zinus vs Tuft and Needle comparison. As from what I’ve heard from others, this does mean that the longevity of the mattress is less. So if you’re not looking for a mattress that you’ll be able to sleep on for the next 10+ years, you’re good to go.

zinus layers

What I like about the Tuft and Needle mattress: premium mattress for an affordable price

tuft and needle vs zinus

Now, the Tuft & Needle mattress really looks like (and sleeps like) a premium mattress. It’s very comfortable and seems to hit that sweet spot between soft and firm right away. It’s still more affordable than other premium mattresses (that often go for $1000+). And the reason for that is that it’s a very minimalistic mattress. You won’t find many extra’s such as edge support or extra specialized foam layers in the mattress.

It just does what you need from a good mattress: it’s comfortable and offers ample support for your back so you sleep with good posture. I’d recommend this mattress if your budget allows it – because it’s the better option from the 2 and the longevity is also better.

tuft needle vs zinus

Here’s what to base your decision on

I have dropped some hints along this article, but to make the decision easier – here’s an overview of questions you can ask yourself to become clear which mattress is the right option for you:

  • Do you want a premium mattress for a non-premium price? Pick Tuft & Needle
  • Are you alright with trading some longevity/comfortability of the mattress for a reduction in price? Zinus mattress
  • Do you weigh more than 250 pounds? Zinus mattress
  • Is comfort very important for you? Then go for the Tuft & Needle mattress


Final verdict Zinus vs Tuft and Needle

So there we have it. In general, the Zinus mattress has a lower price tag – but it comes with the cost of less comfort and longevity. So if you have the budget, I’d recommend you go for Tuft & Needle. However, if you’re just looking for a memory foam mattress that is comfortable enough and will last you at least a couple of years – then the Zinus mattress may be good with its lower price tag.

If you want more information, I recommend you check out the respective product pages on Amazon. There you’ll find a lot more information (features and prices) + many helpful customer reviews that can guide your decision.


Click here for more information about the Zinus mattress!


And here if you want to know more about the Tuft & Needle mattress!



P.S. quick recap of the Zinus vs Tuft and Needle comparison: Tuft & Needle is the overall better choice for comfort and longevity – however this comes with the price tag. So if you’re willing to trade some comfort for a lower price, you can go for the Zinus mattress.

By Adrianus

Since childhood I've tried hundreds of little experiments to feel better, learn faster and perform higher (e.g. supplements, sports, psychological tricks, sleep and wacky diets).
After I graduated university in 2016, I basically found that sleep was the #1 factor to improve every aspect of life.
Bad sleep = bad life. I started SleepInvestor in 2017 to share my experiments and thoughts about sleep.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *